1. Introduction
Version followed: Japanese Shingon (真言宗) esoteric Buddhism founded by Kūkai (空海, Kōbō Daishi, 774–835), as presented by Kōyasan Shingon-shū and its head temple Kongōbu-ji (金剛峯寺, founded 816 on Mount Kōya), by Shingon temples' own public explanations of ajikan and goma, and by Japanese reference encyclopedias; scholarly framing from Payne (2021). The lay-accessible forms are followed throughout; priestly and initiatory forms are outlined only. [source: MLIT 金剛峯寺; Kudoji ajikan and goma leaflets; Kotobank 護摩; Payne 2021]
What it is. Three linked elements of Shingon practice that a client may bring to therapy:
- The Three Mysteries (三密 sanmitsu): the body, speech and mind of the cosmic buddha Mahāvairocana (Dainichi Nyorai, 大日如来), engaged by the practitioner through mudrā (hand seals, body), mantra (speech) and meditation or visualization (mind). Practice of the three is said to make possible sokushin jōbutsu (即身成仏), "buddhahood in this very body". [source: Korinji Mikkyo page; Wikipedia Shingon [uncertain: secondary, unverified]]
- Ajikan (阿字観): meditation on the Siddhaṃ letter A, which the tradition holds to represent Dainichi Nyorai and the life shared by all beings. A temple leaflet describes it as once a secret teaching that the sect has opened to the general public; it pictures the body as a lotus and the mind as a moon disc (月輪 gachirin) that gradually expands until the practitioner feels one with the macrocosm. On Kōya, a government publication describes it as a distinctive Shingon breathing and meditation method taught directly by monks at the Ajikan Dōjō. [source: Kudoji ajikan leaflet; gov-online Koyasan feature]
- Goma (護摩): a fire rite whose name transcribes Sanskrit homa (burning). Encyclopedias distinguish the outer goma (外護摩, a real fire on an altar hearth into which offerings and goma sticks are placed) from the inner goma (内護摩, contemplative burning of one's own afflictions in the wisdom-fire of the Buddha). The usual central deity is Fudō Myōō (不動明王, Acala). [source: Kotobank 護摩; Kudoji goma leaflet; Payne 2021]
Core idea of change, as the tradition states it. Delusion and afflictions (煩悩 bonnō) are the "firewood" that the Buddha's wisdom-fire burns away; by aligning body, speech and mind with those of Dainichi Nyorai, the small, ego-bound self is understood to open into identity with the whole. Goma is also performed to fulfil prayers (protection from calamity and illness, increase of benefit, harmonious relationships, subduing of obstacles), each of which encyclopedias also read inwardly as the removal or transformation of one's own afflictions. These are religious claims, attributed to the tradition, neither affirmed nor dismissed here; no rite is presented as a treatment for physical disease, and clinical evidence for health effects of goma or ajikan is not cited here [uncertain: not verified]. [source: Kotobank 護摩; Kudoji goma leaflet]
What this guide is. This is an observance, not a psychotherapy. The therapist does not teach or perform ajikan, mudrā, mantra or goma. The guide describes the practices as their institutions publish them and then sets out the psychotherapist's own work alongside them: meaning, cultural assessment, accommodation, health coordination, scrupulosity, meditation-related difficulties, grief and community, and collaboration with priests. [synthesis]
2. Framework
2a. How the tradition structures participation (as published)
| Level | What happens | Who leads or authorises | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lay attendance at goma | Lay people attend a goma in a goma hall (護摩堂 gomadō) before the main image and altar; offerings and goma sticks are burned; prayer requests may be submitted, and wooden or paper prayer tablets (護摩札 gomafuda) may be kept as protective talismans. Some temples let non-members send prayer requests remotely. | A priest who has completed goma training; the chōbuku (subduing) rite is reserved for senior ajari (阿闍梨, ācārya) | Kudoji goma leaflet; Kotobank 護摩; Korinji Mikkyo page |
| Public ajikan sessions | The sect has adapted ajikan so ordinary people can learn it; on Kōya it is taught by monks, often to temple-lodging (宿坊 shukubō) guests. The hanging scroll (掛軸本尊) shows the letter A in a moon disc above a lotus. | Shingon monks and temples | Kudoji ajikan leaflet; gov-online Koyasan feature |
| Kechien kanjō (結縁灌頂) | Described as the only initiation ceremony for lay practitioners, forming a bond with Mahāvairocana. | Qualified ajari | Wikipedia Shingon [uncertain: secondary, unverified] |
| Priestly path | Novice ordination and precepts, study, then the fourfold preliminary training (四度加行 shido kegyō), whose final part is the goma; teaching passes orally (口伝 kuden) under a qualified master and varies by lineage. | Ordained teachers within each Shingon school (e.g. Kōyasan, Chisan, Buzan) | Wikipedia Shingon [uncertain: secondary, unverified]; Payne 2021 |
The detailed content of initiation, the mudrā–mantra sequences and the priest's goma manual are transmitted from teacher to student and are restricted; this guide gives none of them. [source: Korinji Mikkyo page; Payne 2021]
2b. Phases of the therapist's work alongside the practice [synthesis]
No source gives a session count or format for psychotherapy alongside Shingon practice; the phases below are a working structure, not a protocol.
- Orientation and assessment. Goal: learn what the client practises (lay or ordained; goma attendance, ajikan, recitation, pilgrimage), how it fits their life, and whether it helps or troubles them, using the Cultural Formulation Interview (CFI) and its Spirituality, Religion and Moral Traditions module. Move on when the role of the practice in the presenting problem is mapped and the client has said how, or whether, they want it to figure in therapy.
- Agreement on scope. Goal: agree consent, roles and boundaries (the therapist is not a priest or meditation teacher), and whether and how to involve a priest. Move on when this is explicit and recorded.
- Working phase. Goal: apply the chosen interventions from section 4 (meaning-making, accommodation, health coordination, scrupulosity work, management of meditation-related difficulty, grief work) within the client's existing treatment plan. Move on when the client's goals for this strand are met or the strand stops being relevant.
- Review and handover. Goal: review what helped; plan relapse prevention (for example, early signs of scrupulous checking or of destabilising meditation experiences) and continuing links with the temple community if the client wants them.
3. Guiding principles
- Describe, attribute, do not adjudicate. Present Dainichi Nyorai, Fudō Myōō, the wisdom-fire and sokushin jōbutsu as the tradition holds them. Practical meaning: use the client's terms ("the Daishi", "Fudō-sama", "the moon disc") and reflect them back without endorsing or debunking. [synthesis; source for terms: Kudoji leaflets, Kotobank]
- Client-led integration. The client decides whether their practice enters therapy at all. Practical meaning: ask before drawing on imagery or rites; never assign ajikan or goma-style exercises as homework. [synthesis]
- Respect restriction and transmission. Esoteric methods are passed on privately by qualified teachers through oral instruction. Practical meaning: do not ask the client to disclose initiatory content, do not teach mudrā or mantra, and do not encourage self-initiation from books or videos; refer technical questions to their teacher. [source: Korinji Mikkyo page; Payne 2021]
- The therapist is not a priest. Practical meaning: no prayers performed for the client, no goma requests submitted on their behalf, no guidance on correct ritual form. [synthesis]
- Health questions go to the doctor. Practical meaning: a goma for recovery from illness sits alongside medical care, never instead of it; physical symptoms during practice (smoke, heat, long kneeling or sitting, fasting or austerities during priestly training) are raised with the client's physician. [synthesis]
- Meditation can have adverse effects. Challenging experiences occur even in people with no psychiatric history and can last from days to years. Practical meaning: ask routinely about difficult experiences during ajikan or retreats, and do not assume they are either pathology or progress. [source: Brown 2017 news on Lindahl et al.; Acta Psychiatr Scand 2020 review]
- Separate OCD from faith. Scrupulosity goes beyond or ignores religious teaching and is driven by distress rather than devotion. Practical meaning: treat ritual-precision fears with ERP while protecting the client's religious values, consulting their religious authority if they wish. [source: IOCDF]
- Collaboration only with consent. Practical meaning: contact with a priest, ajari or temple happens only at the client's request and with written consent; clarify what will be shared. [source: IOCDF on involving religious leaders; synthesis]
- Watch the power of the teacher relationship. Lindahl et al. found teacher relationships could be supportive or distressing. Practical meaning: explore how the client experiences their teacher and temple, with the same curiosity as any significant relationship. [source: Brown 2017 news]
- Be even-handed about the therapist's own commitments. Practical meaning: keep self-disclosure about your own religion or non-religion brief and purposeful; seek consultation when your views pull on the work. Published spiritual and religious competencies (Vieten et al. 2013) [uncertain: not verified] and the APA Ethics Code support this. [synthesis]
4. Intervention inventory
All interventions below are the psychotherapist's own work alongside Shingon practice. None teaches or performs a Shingon rite. Steps and example language are [synthesis] unless a source is tagged; example language is illustrative wording, not quoted from any teacher.
4.1 Exploring what the practice means in the client's life
- Purpose / when: At intake or whenever the client mentions Kōya, a temple, goma, ajikan, Fudō or the Daishi. Establishes whether the practice is a resource, a source of stress, a family obligation, a cultural identity marker, or all of these. [synthesis]
- Steps:
- Ask what they do (attend goma, request prayers, keep a gomafuda, sit ajikan, pilgrimage, temple lodging, ordained training) and since when.
- Ask what it is for, in their words: protection, recovery, family duty, inner calm, "burning away" something.
- Ask who else is involved: family temple (菩提寺 bodaiji), a particular priest, a pilgrimage group.
- Ask what happens inside them before, during and after.
- Summarise and check: "Is this how you'd put it?"
- Example language (illustrative): "When you go to the goma, what are you hoping for? What do you take home with you?" / "You said the fire burns away what you don't need. What would you most want it to burn?"
- Watch for: Over-reading the practice as purely symbolic when the client experiences it as efficacious, or vice versa; shame about "superstition" in clients from secularised Japanese families; family conflict over temple obligations. Working if the client talks about the practice freely and links it to their goals.
4.2 Cultural Formulation Interview with the Spirituality, Religion and Moral Traditions module
- Purpose / when: Structured cultural assessment, especially when religious practice touches the presenting problem or when the therapist is unfamiliar with Shingon. The APA's supplementary module explores five areas: spiritual or religious identity and community ties, the tradition's role in daily and family life, practices and their importance, whether the tradition has helped the person cope, and whether it has contributed to stress, distress, discrimination or conflict. [source: APA CFI Supplementary Modules]
- Steps:
- Use the core CFI first; add the module where religion is salient. The module can also be used on its own. [source: APA CFI Supplementary Modules]
- Insert the client's own name for the tradition (for example "Shingon", "the Daishi's teaching", "our family temple") into the questions, as the module instructs. [source: APA CFI Supplementary Modules]
- Explore each tradition separately if the client holds several (Shingon alongside Shintō observance, Christianity or none is common in Japanese families). [source: APA CFI Supplementary Modules; synthesis for the Japanese example]
- Where the client reports specific practices (goma, ajikan), ask about level of involvement and how it affects coping. [source: APA CFI Supplementary Modules]
- Add the Explanatory Model and Coping and Help-Seeking modules if the client sees the problem in religious terms (karmic, protective, ancestral). [source: APA CFI Supplementary Modules lists these modules; synthesis for the pairing]
- Example language (illustrative): "Has the temple, or your practice, helped with what brought you here? Has any part of it made things harder?"
- Watch for: Paraphrase rather than read the form aloud; the APA permits clinical use of the instrument but do not reproduce it in client materials beyond what the permission covers. Working if the formulation includes the client's own account of the practice's role.
4.3 Clarifying lay, initiatory and priestly levels
- Purpose / when: When a client describes practices learned from books, online videos or a temple, or is considering kechien kanjō or ordination. Shingon esoteric methods are transmitted privately by teachers; initiation, priest training and the chōbuku rite are restricted to qualified people. [source: Korinji Mikkyo page; Kudoji goma leaflet; Payne 2021; Wikipedia Shingon [uncertain: secondary, unverified]]
- Steps:
- Ask where and from whom they learned the practice.
- Distinguish openly offered forms (public ajikan sessions, attending goma) from restricted ones (initiations, priest's goma, mudrā–mantra sequences).
- If they are improvising restricted methods without a teacher, explore why, without judgement, and suggest they consult a qualified priest of a recognised Shingon temple.
- Do not ask them to tell you initiatory content; if they start to, it is their choice, but say you do not need it.
- Example language (illustrative): "That sounds like something a teacher would normally pass on in person. Is there a priest you could ask about it?" / "You don't need to tell me anything you've been asked to keep private."
- Watch for: The therapist being drawn into evaluating ritual correctness; self-taught intensive practice combined with isolation (a risk factor to explore, see 4.8). Working if the client has a clear, safe route for practice questions outside therapy.
4.4 Client-led use of ajikan imagery in session
- Purpose / when: Only when a client who already practises ajikan under a Shingon teacher asks to draw on it for grounding or perspective. The publicly described imagery is the body as a lotus, the mind as a moon disc, and the small self gradually widening into oneness with Dainichi Nyorai; the tradition describes the result as a vast, relaxed state that clears confusion and lets one look at oneself more clearly. [source: Kudoji ajikan leaflet]
- Steps:
- Confirm the request comes from the client and that they practise ajikan already; obtain and note consent.
- Ask the client to describe, in their own words, how their teacher taught them; the client leads, the therapist does not instruct posture, breathing or recitation.
- Offer a short space in session for them to recall the image (moon disc, lotus) with eyes open or closed, as they prefer, and agree a signal to stop.
- Afterwards, explore what they noticed and how it relates to the therapy goal (for example, seeing a problem from a wider view).
- If they want this for home use, refer them back to their teacher for method; therapy discusses meaning and effects only.
- Example language (illustrative): "You mentioned the moon disc helps you feel less trapped in your own head. Would you like to take a moment with that image now, the way you were taught? Stop whenever you like."
- Watch for: The breathing component of ajikan (阿息観, silent recitation of A with the breath) is taught by monks and is not to be taught or modified by the therapist; dissociation, depersonalisation or a loss of the sense of self when the "small self" is asked to expand, especially in clients with trauma histories (see 4.8); using imagery to avoid painful material. Working if the client feels steadier and more able to engage, not more detached. [source for breath component: Kudoji ajikan leaflet; rest synthesis]
4.5 Working with goma prayer intentions
- Purpose / when: When the client has requested or plans a goma prayer (for recovery, protection, exam success, family harmony) or keeps a gomafuda. The rite is understood both as fulfilling prayers and as burning afflictions in the wisdom-fire; encyclopedias give the categories of protection from calamity and illness (息災 sokusai), increase of benefit (増益 zōyaku), love and harmony (敬愛 keiai) and subduing (調伏 chōbuku), with inner readings for each. [source: Kotobank 護摩; Kudoji goma leaflet]
- Steps:
- Ask what the prayer request is and what it expresses about the client's hopes and fears.
- Explore the inner reading the tradition itself offers: what afflictions (anger, craving, confusion) the client would want "burned".
- Link the intention to concrete therapy goals and values-based actions the client can take alongside the prayer.
- Where the request concerns illness, check the client is also following medical advice (see 4.7).
- Example language (illustrative): "The tradition says the fire burns afflictions as well as answering prayers. If you think about it that way, what would you be offering up?"
- Watch for: Prayer requests that function as compulsive reassurance (repeated requests after every worry: see 4.9); anger at a person expressed as wanting them "subdued": explore the conflict and any risk directly, while respecting that the tradition reads subduing also as cutting one's own afflictions [synthesis]; financial pressure from repeated donations. Working if the practice supports agency rather than replacing it.
4.6 Accommodation in scheduling and treatment
- Purpose / when: When temple duties, monthly goma, festival days, pilgrimage, temple lodging or ordained training periods collide with therapy. Temples hold goma on regular, often monthly, schedules. [source: Korinji Mikkyo page; rest synthesis]
- Steps:
- Ask about the client's ritual calendar at the start and at each review.
- Plan sessions, exposure homework and medication reviews (with the prescriber) around it.
- For clients entering an extended training period with limited contact, agree a plan before they go: emergency contacts, who at the temple knows about their mental health (if they consent), and a return session.
- Example language (illustrative): "Are there any temple days or retreats coming up we should plan around?"
- Watch for: Avoidance disguised as religious duty (or the reverse: a therapist reading real duty as avoidance). Working if attendance and practice coexist without crisis.
4.7 Health issues and coordination with the client's doctor
- Purpose / when: When practice has a physical side or the client links it to illness. Goma involves sitting close to an open fire in an enclosed hall; ajikan involves prolonged seated meditation; priestly preliminary training is described as rigorous and includes a retreat. No clinical guidance specific to these practices is cited here [uncertain: not verified]; the steps below are general practice. [source: Kudoji goma leaflet; Wikipedia Shingon [uncertain: secondary, unverified]; rest synthesis]
- Steps:
- Ask about respiratory conditions (smoke), heat tolerance, joint or back problems (kneeling, seated posture), and, for ordained trainees, sleep, diet and exertion during training periods, described qualitatively.
- With consent, raise any concerns with the client's physician; the therapist does not advise on medicines, diet or exertion.
- If the client hopes a goma or ajikan will cure a physical illness, acknowledge the hope, state plainly that this is a religious practice rather than a medical treatment, and support continued medical care.
- Ask whether their temple or teacher allows adaptation (sitting on a chair, shorter attendance); the client asks, not the therapist.
- Example language (illustrative): "Many people pray for recovery and keep seeing their doctor too. How are you doing with the medical side?"
- Watch for: Stopping treatment in favour of prayer; smoke-triggered asthma; exhaustion or sleep loss during training. Working if medical care continues and the client feels the practice and treatment are compatible.
4.8 Meditation-related difficulties: screening, grounding and differential assessment
- Purpose / when: For any client practising ajikan, attending retreats or temple stays, or practising intensively alone. Lindahl et al. (2017, PLOS ONE) interviewed nearly 100 Western Buddhist meditators and teachers (Theravada, Zen, Tibetan) and built a taxonomy of 59 challenging experiences in seven domains (cognitive, perceptual, affective, somatic, conative, sense of self, social), such as light or sound hypersensitivity, insomnia, involuntary movements, fear, panic or loss of emotion; durations ranged from days to over a decade, and influencing factors included practitioner, practice, relationship and health-behaviour factors. A 2020 systematic review in Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica (83 studies) found adverse events in about 8% overall (about 4% in experimental, 33% in observational studies), most often anxiety, depression and cognitive anomalies, including in people with no prior mental-health history. Shingon ajikan was not specifically studied [uncertain: not verified]. [source: Brown 2017 news; PubMed 32820538]
- Steps:
- Screen before intensive retreats or temple stays: psychiatric history (psychosis, mania, dissociation, recent trauma), sleep, substance use, current stressors, support at the venue. Assessment before intensive retreats is recommended in the clinical literature [uncertain: not verified; synthesis].
- Ask routinely about unusual experiences across the seven domains, normalising that they happen.
- Reduce dose and ground when experiences destabilise: suggest the client discuss with their teacher shortening or pausing formal practice; meanwhile use eyes-open orientation to the room, physical activity, regular sleep and meals, social contact. [synthesis; Lindahl et al. reported that talking with someone familiar with such experiences was a commonly cited remedy: source Brown 2017 news]
- Trauma-sensitive adaptation: offer choice, eyes open, shorter periods and the option to stop, consistent with trauma-sensitive mindfulness as described by Treleaven (2018) [uncertain: not verified]; avoid encouraging dissolution of self-boundaries in clients with dissociation.
- Differentiate a spiritual or meditation-related crisis from psychosis, mania, depression or dissociation: check insight, functioning, sleep, risk, and whether the experience fits the practitioner's tradition and is time-limited. Do not pathologise expected contemplative experiences, and do not miss illness. DSM-5-TR includes a code for a religious or spiritual problem (Z65.8). Refer urgently for psychiatric assessment when there is risk, persistent loss of reality testing, or manic symptoms.
- Coordinate with the teacher if the client wishes; specialised support for meditation-related difficulties, such as Britton's Cheetah House, also exists [uncertain: not verified].
- Example language (illustrative): "Some people find ajikan brings up unusual or frightening experiences, like feeling unreal or very sensitive to sound. Has anything like that happened to you?"
- Watch for: The client hiding experiences for fear of being called mentally ill, or being told by peers to "practise through it". Working if symptoms settle with grounding and reduced practice, and the client can decide about resuming with their teacher.
4.9 Scrupulosity: ritual precision, purity and reassurance
- Purpose / when: When a client fears they performed a mudrā, recitation, offering or prayer request incorrectly; repeats prayers until they feel "right"; repeatedly asks priests for reassurance; repeatedly requests goma for fear of misfortune; or avoids the temple for fear of committing an error. The IOCDF lists excessive confession, rewriting or repeating prayers, repeated reassurance from clergy and cleansing rituals as common compulsions, and avoidance of services or texts as avoidance behaviour. [source: IOCDF]
- Steps:
- Assess for OCD in the usual way. Use the IOCDF markers: behaviour that goes beyond or ignores religious teaching, fixates on one practice while neglecting central ones, is inconsistent with the community, is driven by distress rather than devotion, and causes impairment. [source: IOCDF]
- Explain that ERP is the main psychological treatment and that its goal is to separate the OCD from the client's religious values so they can live by them. [source: IOCDF]
- With consent, consult a priest of the client's temple to clarify what the tradition actually requires (for example, whether an imperfect recitation invalidates a rite), so exposures stay within religious norms. The IOCDF notes religious leaders may help clarify their institution's position. [source: IOCDF; synthesis for the Shingon example]
- Build a hierarchy of exposures that are religiously acceptable (attending goma without re-checking, leaving a recitation "imperfect", not requesting extra prayers), with response prevention of checking and reassurance. Obtain informed consent and explain expected anxiety; do not use exposures that would violate the client's sincere religious commitments.
- Address reassurance-seeking from priests jointly if the client agrees.
- Example language (illustrative): "Let's find out what your temple actually asks of you. Then we can practise doing exactly that much, and no more, while the anxiety rises and falls."
- Watch for: Exposures framed as attacks on faith; mental compulsions (silent re-recitation, re-visualising) replacing overt ones. Working if ritual time shrinks, distress falls and the client reports practice feeling devotional again. Medication questions go to the prescriber.
4.10 Grief, memorial rites and community support
- Purpose / when: When the client is bereaved and the family temple conducts memorial services, or when a goma prayer was offered for someone who died. [synthesis; Shingon memorial practice: uncertain, not verified]
- Steps:
- Ask what rites the family is observing and what they mean to the client.
- Explore feelings about prayers that "did not work", including guilt, anger at the deity or temple, or doubt.
- Support the client in drawing on temple and family community if they wish; respect clients who find rites empty or burdensome.
- Example language (illustrative): "You asked for a goma for your father and he still died. What has that been like for your faith?"
- Watch for: Complicated grief; self-blame over ritual "mistakes" (see 4.9). Working if the client can hold both grief and their relationship to the practice.
4.11 Collaboration with priests and temples
- Purpose / when: At the client's request, when practice questions, accommodation, scrupulosity or a destabilising experience need the teacher's input. [source: IOCDF on involving religious leaders; rest synthesis]
- Steps:
- Obtain written consent specifying who is contacted and what is shared.
- Agree the purpose of contact (clarifying requirements, adapting practice, safety plan).
- Keep roles clear: the priest advises on practice; the therapist on mental health.
- Report back to the client and record the outcome.
- Example language (illustrative): "Would it help if I spoke with your priest about how much practice is wise right now? You decide what I share."
- Watch for: Pressure from family or temple for contact the client does not want. Working if advice from both sides is consistent.
4.12 The teacher relationship, power and coercive control
- Purpose / when: When the client is closely bound to a teacher or group, describes pressure, or wants to leave. Lindahl et al. found teacher relationships could be supportive or distressing. Independent investigations of misconduct relating to the practices covered here: none found in the sources consulted. [source: Brown 2017 news; rest synthesis]
- Steps:
- Explore the relationship as any significant attachment: benefits, demands, freedom to disagree.
- Ask about signs of coercive control: isolation from family, control of money or information, punishment for questioning, secrecy demands beyond legitimate restriction of ritual content, sexual or financial exploitation.
- Distinguish legitimate restriction (initiatory content kept private) from secrecy about harm.
- If abuse is disclosed, follow safeguarding and reporting duties; support leaving if the client chooses, and address religious trauma and loss of community.
- Example language (illustrative): "Keeping teachings private is part of many traditions. Being asked to keep harm secret is different. Has anything like that happened?"
- Watch for: Labelling a legitimate tradition as harmful, or missing exploitation within it. Working if the client can name and act on their own choices.
4.13 Role boundaries, self-disclosure and competence
- Purpose / when: Throughout, and especially when the client asks the therapist to pray, attend a goma, interpret signs, or share their own beliefs. [synthesis]
- Steps:
- Decline roles of priest, teacher or ritual adviser, warmly, and redirect to the temple.
- Avoid dual relationships (for example, attending the same temple in a role that overlaps with the client's) or discuss and manage them openly.
- Keep self-disclosure about your own religion or non-religion brief and client-focused.
- Seek consultation or training when unfamiliar with Shingon; professional spiritual and religious competencies (Vieten et al. 2013) [uncertain: not verified] and the APA Ethics Code frame this.
- Example language (illustrative): "I'm not the right person to say whether the rite was done properly; your priest is. What I can help with is how the worry is affecting you."
- Watch for: Over-identification with, or quiet contempt for, the client's tradition. Working if the client feels respected and roles stay clear.
4.14 Children and family involvement
- Purpose / when: When a minor takes part in temple activities or a family wants a child included in prayers or rites. [synthesis]
- Steps: Seek the child's assent and the parents' consent for anything discussed in therapy; ask whether participation is voluntary and age-appropriate; follow local safeguarding procedures if any practice involves harm, exhaustion or coercion. No safeguarding guidance specific to Shingon is cited here [uncertain: not verified].
- Example language (illustrative): "What do you like about going to the temple? Is there anything you'd rather not do?"
- Watch for: Distress the child cannot voice in front of parents. Working if the child's own view is heard.
5. Handling problems
Unless tagged otherwise, guidance in this section is [synthesis]; the sources cited do not address psychotherapy alongside Shingon practice directly.
- Client wants the therapist to teach or correct ajikan, mudrā or mantra. Decline, explain that these are transmitted by teachers, and help the client find or return to a qualified Shingon priest. [source for transmission by teachers: Korinji Mikkyo page]
- Client is self-teaching restricted practices from online material, in isolation. Explore motives (loneliness, distrust of temples, searching for intense experience); screen for meditation-related difficulties (4.8); encourage contact with a teacher and a community.
- Client is "stuck": practice has become routine or empty. Treat this as meaningful material, not failure; explore doubt, grief or changing identity using CFI questions on coping and conflict (4.2). Some clients will step back from practice; support their choice either way. [source for CFI domains: APA CFI Supplementary Modules]
- Resistance to discussing religion in therapy. Respect it; note it in the formulation and revisit only if the client raises the practice. Some clients fear being judged as superstitious; name this possibility gently.
- Overwhelm during or after ajikan or a temple stay (panic, unreality, insomnia, involuntary movements, intense energy sensations). Ground first, reduce or pause practice in consultation with the teacher, assess for psychosis, mania or dissociation, and refer for urgent psychiatric assessment where indicated. These experience types match those catalogued by Lindahl et al. [source: Brown 2017 news; PubMed 32820538 for frequency of adverse events]
- Non-adherence to medical treatment in favour of goma prayers. Validate the prayer; restate that it is not a medical treatment; with consent, coordinate with the doctor and, if the client wishes, the priest, who may affirm that prayer and medicine go together [uncertain: whether a given temple would say this is not verified].
- Non-adherence to ERP because exposures "feel sacrilegious". Return to step 3 of 4.9: clarify with the client's religious authority what is actually required; redesign exposures inside those norms. [source: IOCDF]
- Rupture: the client feels the therapist dismissed or exoticised their tradition. Acknowledge directly, ask what landed badly, and repair; check whether the therapist's own beliefs played a part and take it to supervision.
- Family conflict over temple obligations (for example, inheriting duties to a family temple, costs of rites, an ordained family member). Use systemic questions; explore the client's own wishes separately from the family's.
- Anger expressed as wanting an enemy "subdued" through ritual. Explore the conflict and its intensity directly and assess risk to others as usual; acknowledge that the tradition also reads subduing as cutting one's own afflictions [source: Kotobank 護摩 for the inner reading].
- Moral injury or guilt in ordained clients (for example, leaving training, breaking precepts, losing faith while serving). Explore the moral meaning without imposing secular or religious verdicts; with consent, involve a trusted senior priest or a chaplain outside the client's own hierarchy.
- Suspected exploitation by a teacher or temple. Assess for coercive control (4.12), follow safeguarding and legal reporting duties, support access to independent advice, and address religious trauma if the client leaves.
- Therapist unfamiliar with Shingon. Use the CFI to let the client teach you their own understanding; consult a colleague with relevant cultural knowledge; avoid relying on popular or tourist accounts as authoritative.
Sources
Web sources:
- 神秘的な高野山の魅力を体感する (Highlighting Japan, October 2023)
- 金剛峯寺 (Japan Tourism Agency multilingual explanation, MLIT)
- 宇宙の心を生きる: Ajikan leaflet (Hirosaki tourism, Kudoji materials)
- 護摩行とは / What is Gomagyo? (Hirosaki tourism, Kudoji materials)
- 護摩 (Kotobank: entries from 日本大百科全書 by 小野塚幾澄, 世界大百科事典 by 和多秀乗, 精選版 日本国語大辞典, デジタル大辞泉, ブリタニカ国際大百科事典, 百科事典マイペディア)
- Mikkyo (Korinji)
- Payne, R. K. (2021). A Pragmatics of Ritual: The Yoshida Goma at the Interface of Shintō and Shingon. Religions 12(10), 884
- Shingon Buddhism (Wikipedia) [uncertain: secondary, unverified]
- DSM-5 Cultural Formulation Interview Supplementary Modules (American Psychiatric Association, 2013)
- Study documents range of challenging meditation experiences (Brown University, 2017), on Lindahl et al., PLOS ONE 2017
- Adverse events in meditation practices and meditation-based therapies: a systematic review. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 2020;142(5):374–393 (PubMed 32820538), commonly cited as Farias et al. [uncertain: author list not verified]
- What is OCD & Scrupulosity? (International OCD Foundation)
- ICD-10-CM Z65.8, Other specified problems related to psychosocial circumstances (includes 'Religious or spiritual problem'), https://www.unboundmedicine.com/icd/view/ICD-10-CM/945432/all/Z65_8___Other_specified_problems_related_to_psychosocial_circumstances
Also cited [uncertain: not verified]: Treleaven, D. (2018), trauma-sensitive mindfulness; Vieten, C. et al. (2013), spiritual and religious competencies; Britton's Cheetah House resources; the APA Ethics Code; DSM-5-TR code for a religious or spiritual problem; Jitsue's record of oral instruction on ajikan (Taishō no. 2423, as cited on Wikipedia).