Atlas›Domain XIII · Contemplative & religious disciplines›Guide 137
Guide XIII-137

Lizhi, establishing the resolve to become a junzi

Wang Yangming
A 25 · L 63 · M 1216 interventions in the Trinity explorer
Client cardCompare
[source: …] where a claim comes from[uncertain] not confirmed in a primary source[synthesis] the writer's reconstruction

1. Introduction

Version followed: Wang Yangming (王陽明, Wang Shouren, 1472–1529), as he taught it in Instructions to the Students at Longchang (教條示龍場諸生) and Essay on Establishing Resolve, Shown to My Younger Brother (示弟立志說). The Chinese text is taken from quotations in modern Confucian and educational sources, and the reading follows Julia Ching's 1971 ANU thesis, The "Way" of Wang Yang-ming. The Cheng–Zhu (Zhu Xi) version of lizhi is not set out here [uncertain: not verified].

Lizhi (立志, "establishing the will" or "setting the resolve") is the first discipline in Confucian and Neo-Confucian self-cultivation (修身, 工夫). It means committing oneself, deliberately and for life, to becoming a junzi (君子, the morally exemplary person) and ultimately a sage (聖人). It is a contemplative practice in the broad sense: a self-cultivation method the tradition teaches openly. It is not a meditation technique and has no secret or initiatory content. Wang made it the first of four guidelines for his students at Longchang, followed by diligent learning (勤學), correcting faults (改過) and exhorting one another to goodness (責善) [source: Hong Kong EDB; rujiazg.com, Gong 2015].

The tradition's account of how change happens: "志不立，天下無可成之事" (if the resolve is not established, nothing in the world can be accomplished). Without it a person is "如無舵之舟，無銜之馬" (a boat without a rudder, a horse without a bit) [source: 教條示龍場諸生, quoted in Gong 2015 and EDB]. A firmly set aim gives every later effort its direction, its test and its energy. For Wang the aim is not an outside target. It is rooted in liangzhi (良知, innate moral knowing), the goodness he held is already present in every mind. Sagehood is reached by clearing away selfish desires, as one polishes a mirror, and it is open to everyone [source: Ching 1971, pp. 96–97; EDB].

For the psychotherapist: lizhi comes into therapy when a client from a Confucian, Neo-Confucian or East Asian heritage (or a student of these traditions) wants to work from it. The clinician supports the client's own practice and translates between it and clinical goals, with consent. The clinician does not teach the tradition [synthesis].

2. Framework

The tradition does not lay out sessions. It describes an ordering of practice:

  • Root: establishing the resolve (立志). Goal: a single-minded commitment to becoming a sage or worthy ("立志而聖則聖矣，立志而賢則賢矣": set the resolve on sagehood and one becomes a sage; set it on worthiness and one becomes a worthy) [source: 教條示龍場諸生, quoted in rujiazg 12302]. Wang called making up one's mind in this single-minded way the first step, and criticised asking beginners for what only experts can do [source: Ching 1971, pp. 117–118].
  • Sustaining the resolve at all times. "君子之學，無時無處而不以立志為事" (in the learning of the junzi there is no time and no place where establishing the resolve is not the task). Wang held that a lifetime of study comes down to establishing this resolve [source: 示弟立志說 and related letters, quoted in rujiazg 12302].
  • Expressions and tests of the resolve: diligent learning (lack of diligence shows the resolve "is not yet firm"), correcting faults, and mutual exhortation among friends [source: Gong 2015].
  • Daily work: examining oneself and overcoming selfish thoughts the moment they arise (省察克治). Quiet sitting (靜坐) is a remedy for beginners, balanced with action. Knowledge is joined to action (知行合一) [source: Ching 1971, pp. 101–108].

The stages are not sequential and none is ever finished. The resolve is renewed whenever it weakens. No source gives a session count, length or format [uncertain: not verified].

Clinical framework (all [synthesis]): (1) Assessment and consent: what lizhi means to this client, how it shows up in the presenting problem, and screening for scrupulosity, depression and family or academic pressure. (2) Clarifying the resolve: help the client put their own aim into words, in their own tradition's terms. (3) Linking resolve and daily life: self-examination, correcting faults and acting on the aim, done in a self-compassionate and non-scrupulous way. (4) Maintenance: the community of friends and teachers, and relapse into shame or drift. Move from (1) to (2) once the client has given informed consent to bring the practice in and scrupulosity or acute risk has been ruled out or addressed. Move from (2) to (3) once the client can say the aim in a sentence that feels like theirs, not imposed. Move to (4) once fault correction leads to concrete action without escalating self-reproach.

3. Guiding principles

Tradition principles [source: Gong 2015; rujiazg 12302; EDB; Ching 1971]:

  • Resolve comes first (夫學，莫先於立志). Practical meaning: before technique, ask what the client is fundamentally committed to becoming.
  • The aim is goodness, not success. The EDB reading glosses 志 as grounded in liangzhi and 事 as good conduct. Learning aims at character, not top rankings or family honour. Practical meaning: help the client tell moral resolve apart from achievement pressure.
  • Sagehood is open to everyone and depends on quality, not quantity. Wang held that becoming a sage depends on the quality of virtue, not the amount of knowledge (Ching pp. 99–100). Practical meaning: counter "I am not clever, disciplined or worthy enough" thinking.
  • Without resolve, learning has no roots (學不立志，如植木無根). Wang wrote this in a letter to Zhang Shiwen. Practical meaning: when practice feels empty, go back to the aim before adding effort.
  • Diligence tests the resolve. Practical meaning: stalled effort is treated as information about the resolve, not as proof of bad character.
  • Correcting faults matters more than being faultless (不貴於無過，而貴於能改過). Practical meaning: frame lapses as occasions for correction, not for self-condemnation.
  • Counsel with sincerity and tact (忠告而善道之). Practical meaning: any challenge, including the therapist's, is given respectfully and skilfully.
  • Knowledge is completed in action (知行合一). Practical meaning: a resolve is real only when it shapes concrete conduct this week.
  • Quiet is a remedy, not a refuge. Wang warned against a "fondness for silence" that turns into disgust with action (Ching pp. 106–108). Practical meaning: watch for withdrawal disguised as cultivation.
  • Do not put on a sage's bearing. Wang warned that this drives others away (Ching p. 100). Practical meaning: watch for self-righteousness and moral superiority in the client, and in yourself.

Clinical principles [synthesis unless tagged]:

  • Client-led integration. Work with lizhi only at the client's invitation, in the client's own tradition, language and terms (Chinese, Korean, Japanese or Vietnamese readings differ).
  • The therapist is not a Confucian teacher. Refer textual and doctrinal questions to scholars, academies or teachers the client trusts.
  • Separate value from compulsion. Moral self-examination can become scrupulosity. The IOCDF notes that OCD "can masquerade as religion" [source: IOCDF].
  • Respect, without endorsing or dismissing. Concepts such as liangzhi, Heaven's principle (天理) and sagehood are described as the tradition holds them.
  • Ethics and competence. Avoid dual roles. Be transparent about your own commitments when relevant. Use your profession's ethics code and spiritual and religious competency guidance [synthesis; APA code and Vieten et al. 2013 competencies: uncertain: not verified].

4. Intervention inventory

Part A covers the practices as Wang Yangming's texts and their scholarly readers describe them, with the publicly taught steps in plain paraphrase. Steps that apply them in therapy are marked [synthesis]. Part B covers the psychotherapist's own work. All example language is illustrative wording for the therapist, not words of Wang or any teacher.

Part A. The practice as the tradition teaches it

A1. Establishing the resolve (立志)

  • Purpose and when to use: This is the foundational act of fixing one's life aim on becoming a junzi or sage, grounded in innate moral knowing. It is the starting point (頭腦) that gives study its direction, "as a rudder does for a boat" [source: Ching 1971, p. 84; 教條示龍場諸生 via Gong 2015]. In therapy, use it when a client who holds these values describes drift, lack of direction, or effort that feels rootless.
  • Steps (public teaching, paraphrased): (1) Recognise that without a set aim nothing is accomplished. (2) Choose the aim: sagehood or worthiness, understood as goodness of character, not rank or reputation [source: EDB]. (3) Trust that the aim is attainable because its root, liangzhi, is already present [source: Ching pp. 96–97]. (4) Commit single-mindedly, as a first step suited to a beginner [source: Ching p. 117]. Therapy application [synthesis]: invite the client to write the aim in one or two sentences in their preferred language. Explore what a junzi would mean in their actual roles (child, parent, colleague, citizen). Check that the aim is theirs, not a parent's or teacher's demand.
  • Example language (illustrative): "You've said you want to live as a junzi. In your own words, what does that person do on an ordinary Tuesday?" / "If your resolve were the rudder, which way would it be steering you this month?"
  • Watch for: Aims that are really about status, exam rank or family face. The EDB reading explicitly separates moral resolve from these. Also watch for grandiosity, aims so vast they paralyse, or a resolve stated as an obligation imposed from outside. It is working when the client can state the aim calmly and link it to specific conduct.

A2. Renewing and holding the resolve at all times

  • Purpose and when to use: Wang taught that there is no time and place where establishing the resolve is not the task, and that lifelong learning comes down to this [source: rujiazg 12302]. Use it when a resolve made once has faded.
  • Steps (paraphrased): (1) Treat the resolve as something re-established continually, not a one-off vow. (2) Keep the teaching in front of you. Wang urged his nephews to copy out the Essay on Establishing Resolve and read it regularly [source: rujiazg 12302]. (3) When study or effort slackens, go back to the resolve itself rather than forcing more effort [source: Gong 2015; letter to Zhang Shiwen, "like planting a tree without roots"]. Therapy application [synthesis]: agree with the client on a self-chosen reminder (copying a line from a text they value, a morning reading, a phrase on the phone). Review it briefly at session start, if the client wishes.
  • Example language (illustrative): "When you notice you've drifted, what helps you come back: rereading something, or recalling why you started?"
  • Watch for: Reminders turning into compulsive rituals (rereading until it feels "right"), which is a scrupulosity sign [source: IOCDF]. It is working when returning to the aim lifts motivation rather than guilt.

A3. Diligent learning as the test of resolve (勤學)

  • Purpose and when to use: Wang treated lack of diligence as a sign that the resolve "is not yet firm" (志之尚未篤). He valued diligence, earnestness and humility over quick cleverness [source: Gong 2015]. Use it when a client is discouraged about progress.
  • Steps (paraphrased): (1) Study steadily and humbly, not for display. (2) When diligence fails, examine the resolve rather than condemning oneself. Therapy application [synthesis]: use behavioural activation-style small, scheduled steps linked to the stated aim. Treat a lapse as data ("what weakened the resolve here?"), not as a verdict.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Rather than 'I'm lazy', could we ask what happened to the resolve that day: tiredness, doubt, something it was competing with?"
  • Watch for: Depression presenting as "weak will". Anhedonia, fatigue and low mood need clinical assessment, not more resolve [synthesis]. It is working when lapses lead to curiosity and resumption.

A4. Correcting faults (改過)

  • Purpose and when to use: Even sages err. What is valued is the ability to correct faults, not having none [source: Gong 2015]. Use it when a client is stuck in guilt or concealment after a moral lapse.
  • Steps (paraphrased): (1) Acknowledge the fault honestly. (2) Correct it in conduct. (3) Keep examining and amending. Therapy application [synthesis]: name the fault specifically, identify the repair (apology, restitution, a changed habit), act on it, then close the episode. Pair this with self-compassion (cross-refer Domain II, MSC and CFT).
  • Example language (illustrative): "In this tradition the point isn't to be faultless; it's to correct. What would correcting this look like, concretely, by next week?"
  • Watch for: Endless re-examination of the same fault, repeated confession or reassurance-seeking. These are features of scrupulosity [source: IOCDF]. It is working when correction ends in action and relief rather than more checking.

A5. Exhorting one another to goodness (責善)

  • Purpose and when to use: Friends advise each other, sincerely and skilfully (忠告而善道之). Wang also welcomed his students' criticism [source: Gong 2015]. Wang credited his friendship with Zhan Ruoshui (Chan Jo-shui) with making his own resolve "firmer" and irrevocable [source: Ching pp. 127–128]. Use it when a client is isolated in their practice or receiving harsh, shaming "correction".
  • Steps (paraphrased): (1) Seek companions committed to the same aim. (2) Give counsel sincerely and tactfully, not harshly. (3) Receive counsel without defensiveness. Therapy application [synthesis]: map the client's supports (study group, academy, family elders, friends). Rehearse giving and receiving feedback in the "sincere and skilful" spirit.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Who in your life helps your resolve get firmer, and who makes it feel heavier?"
  • Watch for: Groups where "exhortation" becomes public shaming or control (see Section 5). It is working when the client's relationships support the aim without fear.

A6. Self-examination and overcoming selfish thoughts (省察克治)

  • Purpose and when to use: Wang taught examining oneself when criticised or when results fail (drawing on Mencius), and overcoming a selfish thought the moment it arises, at the root, with the vigilance of a cat watching for mice [source: Ching pp. 98, 103–106]. Modern scholarship also notes Wang's attention to the single arising thought (一念) in its sense of "caution and apprehension" (戒懼) [source: Wang Chuanben 2022 review of Chen Lisheng]. Use it only with clients for whom this is already a valued practice and where scrupulosity has been screened.
  • Steps (public teaching, paraphrased): (1) Turn attention inward when things go wrong rather than blaming others. (2) Notice self-serving intentions as they arise. (3) Let the resolve check them at once. Therapy application [synthesis]: translate this into a brief daily review: one thing I acted on from my aim, one self-serving moment I noticed, one correction. Keep a strict time limit and close it with a neutral or kind statement.
  • Example language (illustrative): "When you noticed that thought, what did your resolve say? And did the noticing end, or did it keep circling?"
  • Watch for: Mental checking, thought-neutralising and fear about what a thought "says" about one's character. These are core scrupulosity features [source: IOCDF]. Also watch for intrusive thoughts being treated as moral faults. It is working when noticing is brief and leads to action.

A7. Quiet sitting (靜坐) as a remedy, with action

  • Purpose and when to use: Wang allowed quiet sitting to help beginners become calm enough to discern selfish desires. He treated it as a remedy, not an end, aimed at removing selfish desire rather than abolishing thought. He later warned against a "fondness for silence" that leads to a "disgust for action" and stressed a balance of activity and tranquillity [source: Ching pp. 105–108]. Quiet sitting is also discussed as a Confucian method in recent scholarship [source: Wang Chuanben 2022]. Public outline only: no posture, breath or timing instructions are given here, and none were found in the sources.
  • Steps: Learn it from a teacher or text the client trusts. In therapy, any calming practice should be brief, eyes-open if preferred, and anchored in the senses or the room [synthesis].
  • Example language (illustrative): "Wang treated quiet sitting as medicine for a restless mind, not a place to stay. How does it leave you: steadier for action, or wanting to withdraw?"
  • Watch for: Withdrawal, isolation, and the challenging meditation experiences research documents. Lindahl et al. (2017) described 59 types in seven domains (cognitive, perceptual, affective, somatic, conative, sense of self, social), lasting days to over a decade, and not confined to people with psychiatric or trauma histories [source: Brown University 2017]. See B5.

A8. Joining knowledge and action (知行合一)

  • Purpose and when to use: For Wang, moral knowledge is incomplete until acted on. "Knowledge first, action later" was the sickness his teaching remedied [source: Ching pp. 101–103]. Use it when a client intellectualises the resolve without changing conduct.
  • Steps (paraphrased): Let each insight into the good be enacted in the situation at hand. Therapy application [synthesis]: end each session with one concrete action that expresses the aim, then review it next time.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Wang would say you don't yet fully know filial care until you do it. What's the doing this week?"
  • Watch for: Rigid perfectionism about doing everything at once. It is working when actions become specific and regular.

Part B. The psychotherapist's work

B1. Assessment and consent to integrate the practice

  • Purpose and when to use: At intake, or whenever a client mentions Confucian ideals, resolve, "becoming a better person" in these terms, or self-cultivation. The aim is to learn what lizhi means in the client's life and to agree whether and how to bring it into therapy.
  • Steps [synthesis]: (1) Ask an open question about the client's moral and spiritual traditions, using the DSM-5-TR Cultural Formulation Interview and its spirituality, religion and moral traditions supplementary module where available [uncertain: not verified]. (2) Ask which texts, teachers, family figures or communities shape the client's understanding (Wang Yangming, Zhu Xi, the Analects, family teaching, a study group). (3) Ask how the resolve relates to the presenting problem: a resource, a burden, or both. (4) Screen for scrupulosity, depression, perfectionism, suicidal ideation linked to failing an ideal, and coercive family or group pressure. (5) Obtain explicit consent, and agree on the therapist's role as a supporter and translator, not a teacher.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Some people find their tradition's ideas about self-cultivation help them in therapy; others find them part of the pressure. Would you like us to make room for this, and if so, how?"
  • Watch for: Reluctance to criticise a revered tradition or family elders. Make it safe to name ambivalence. Also watch for clients who feel the therapist is judging the tradition.

B2. Clarifying the resolve: owned aim versus imposed demand

  • Purpose and when to use: When the language of resolve and becoming a junzi has merged with academic or career pressure, family honour or shame. Wang's teaching, as the EDB gloss reads it, separates moral resolve from rank and family glory [source: EDB].
  • Steps [synthesis]: (1) Write two lists: "what my resolve is for" (character, relationships, conduct) and "what I'm told I must achieve" (marks, posts, income). (2) Explore where each comes from. (3) Rephrase the resolve in the client's own words, centred on goodness of conduct. (4) Link it to one or two values-guided actions. Cross-refer values work in acceptance-based therapies, and the spiritually integrated psychotherapy approaches of Domain VII.
  • Example language (illustrative): "In the reading you showed me, the resolve is about becoming good, not about ranking first. Which parts of the pressure you feel belong to that, and which don't?"
  • Watch for: Guilt about "disloyalty" to parents. Hold both filial respect and the client's own aim. It is working when the client can state an aim that feels both traditional and their own.

B3. Scrupulosity screening and ERP adaptation

  • Purpose and when to use: Moral self-examination, fault-correction and "overcoming every selfish thought" can become the content of OCD. Use this whenever self-cultivation is distressing, time-consuming or impairing.
  • How scrupulosity presents [source: IOCDF]: Fear that a thought or act is a sin or moral violation, and fear of what it says about who one is. Compulsions include excessive confession, reassurance-seeking from leaders or loved ones, praying or checking until it feels "just right", mentally reviewing texts, neutralising "bad" thoughts, and scanning oneself for faithfulness. Avoidance of triggering situations is common. Signs that it is OCD rather than devotion: going beyond or ignoring the tradition's own norms, fixating on one area while neglecting more central ones, being distress-driven, causing impairment, and being inconsistent with the client's community.
  • Steps: ERP is the primary psychological treatment for scrupulosity. Its goal is to separate OCD from the person's values so they can live by them [source: IOCDF]. Involving faith-community figures is optional and depends on the client. They can clarify the tradition's position on questions relevant to recovery [source: IOCDF]. Adaptation for this practice [synthesis]: with consent, consult a teacher or scholar the client respects about what Wang and the tradition actually ask (for example, that correcting faults matters more than being faultless, and that quiet is a remedy, not a requirement). Build exposures that do not ask the client to act against their values: e.g. allowing an intrusive "selfish" thought without neutralising it, ending the daily review after a fixed time, refraining from seeking reassurance after a minor lapse.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Your tradition asks you to correct faults, not to be certain you have none. OCD is asking for certainty. Let's practise giving your tradition its due and OCD less."
  • Watch for: The therapist arguing doctrine. Leave doctrinal judgements to the client's own authorities. It is working when time spent on self-checking falls and valued practice returns.

B4. Referral and collaboration with teachers and scholars

  • Purpose and when to use: When the client wants deeper study, textual guidance, or a community of practice, or when doctrinal questions arise in therapy.
  • Steps [synthesis]: (1) Ask whom the client already trusts: a teacher, an academy (書院), a university course, a family elder, a study group. Confucian educational bodies and curricula teach Wang's Longchang instructions today; for example, they appear in Hong Kong secondary-school classical-sayings material [source: EDB]. (2) With written consent, agree on what will be shared. (3) Keep roles distinct: the teacher teaches, the therapist treats.
  • Example language (illustrative): "I can help with how this resolve is affecting your mood and relationships. For questions about what Wang meant, who would you trust to ask?"
  • Watch for: Teachers or groups who discourage professional help or demand secrecy (see Section 5).

B5. Adverse effects, screening, grounding and trauma-sensitive adaptation

  • Purpose and when to use: Whenever the client practises quiet sitting or intensive self-examination, attends retreats, or reports unusual experiences.
  • What research describes: Challenging meditation-related experiences span cognitive, perceptual, affective (fear, panic, loss of emotion), somatic (insomnia, involuntary movements), conative, sense-of-self and social domains. Some last months or years. Practice intensity, trauma history and the teacher relationship influence them for some people but not all. Even experiences that seem positive can become problematic [source: Brown University 2017, reporting Lindahl et al. 2017, PLOS ONE]. Systematic-review evidence on adverse events (Farias et al. 2020) and Britton's Cheetah House resources are relevant [uncertain: not verified].
  • Steps [synthesis]: (1) Before any intensive retreat or prolonged sitting, screen for psychosis or mania history, active PTSD, dissociation, severe depression and current crises. (2) Reduce the dose: shorter, less frequent sitting; eyes open; movement; return to the action-oriented practices (A3–A5, A8), which Wang himself balanced with quiet. (3) Ground: orient to the room, the senses and present tasks. (4) For trauma survivors, offer choice and control, permit stopping at any time, and avoid introspective demands that trigger self-blame. Trauma-sensitive mindfulness (Treleaven 2018) and trauma-sensitive yoga (Domain IV) are published adaptations [uncertain: not verified].
  • Example language (illustrative): "Wang treated quiet as medicine for beginners and warned against getting too fond of it. Let's adjust the dose and see if action steadies you more right now."
  • Watch for: Insomnia, depersonalisation, panic, persistent perceptual changes, withdrawal from work and relationships.

B6. Telling spiritual difficulty apart from illness

  • Purpose and when to use: When the client reports a profound sense of moral awakening, unity with Heaven and Earth, or a crisis of meaning around the resolve.
  • Steps [synthesis]: (1) Take the experience seriously in the tradition's terms, without labelling it pathological or confirming it as attainment. (2) Assess sleep, functioning, grandiosity, pressured speech, persecutory or bizarre beliefs, suicidality and dissociation. (3) If criteria for psychosis, mania, depression or a dissociative disorder are met, treat or refer promptly. (4) If not, the DSM-5-TR category for a religious or spiritual problem (Z65.8) may fit [source: ICD-10-CM Z65.8].
  • Example language (illustrative): "That sounds very significant to you. Can we also check how you've been sleeping and managing day to day, so we can look after you well while this unfolds?"
  • Watch for: A belief that one has already become a sage and is exempt from ordinary obligations. Wang warned against putting on a sage's bearing [source: Ching p. 100].

B7. Roles, ethics and the therapist's own commitments

  • Purpose and when to use: Throughout. It matters most when the client asks the therapist to judge their moral progress or to act as a teacher.
  • Steps [synthesis]: (1) Decline the role of moral teacher or sage. Reflect the question back to the client's own resolve and authorities. (2) Avoid dual relationships, such as joining the client's study group. (3) Disclose your own commitments only when it serves the client, briefly. (4) Follow your profession's ethics code and religious and spiritual competency guidance [uncertain: not verified].
  • Example language (illustrative): "I'm not the right judge of whether you're becoming a junzi. I can help you notice whether your days are moving toward what you've set your resolve on."
  • Watch for: Idealisation of the therapist as a sage or friend in 責善, and therapist countertransference (admiration or impatience toward the tradition).

B8. Published secular and clinical adaptations

  • Purpose and when to use: When a client wants a culturally congruent frame without religious practice.
  • What exists: Xu, Chang, Hsu and Shiah (2022) proposed a Jun-zi Self-cultivation Model. In it, a person functioning as a xiaoren (小人) can become a junzi through self-cultivation, the junzi is described as a "well-functioning self", and the authors propose the model for psychotherapies suited to Confucian cultures. Clinical procedures are not yet specified in the abstract [source: Xu et al. 2022]. Related adaptations sit in Domain II (MBSR, MBCT, MSC, CFT) and Domain VII (spiritually integrated and contemplative psychotherapy).
  • Steps [synthesis]: Use the xiaoren to junzi contrast as a growth frame, never as a label for the client's character. Combine it with self-compassion for faults.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Some psychologists describe the junzi as a well-functioning self. What would one step toward that look like for you?"
  • Watch for: The frame turning into moral grading of self or others.

5. Handling problems

The sources do not address clinical problems directly. Everything below is [synthesis] unless a source is tagged.

  • "My resolve keeps failing; I'm a xiaoren." Reframe through Wang's teaching that lack of diligence shows the resolve is not yet firm, and that correction matters more than faultlessness [source: Gong 2015]. Move from verdict to renewal: re-state the aim, take one small action. Screen for depression if self-condemnation persists. Illustrative: "In Wang's terms this is a resolve that needs re-establishing, not proof you can't be good."
  • Stuck or intellectualising. The client discusses texts at length without changing conduct. Use the unity of knowledge and action (A8): every session ends with one enacted step [source for the principle: Ching 1971].
  • Overwhelm from an aim set too high. Wang called single-minded commitment the beginner's first step and criticised asking beginners for what only experts can do [source: Ching pp. 117–118]. Shrink the next step, not the resolve.
  • Perfectionism and scrupulosity. If self-examination becomes checking, reassurance-seeking or neutralising, shift to ERP-informed work (B3) and, with consent, consult the client's trusted authority [source: IOCDF]. Do not encourage more self-examination as the cure.
  • Family or academic pressure in the language of resolve. Use B2. Validate filial commitment while separating moral aim from rank and honour, as the EDB reading of Wang does [source: EDB]. Consider family sessions where culturally appropriate.
  • Non-adherence to agreed practices. Explore whether the practice is the client's own or a therapist suggestion. Drop anything that feels imposed. Lizhi is self-chosen by definition.
  • Withdrawal into quiet sitting. Wang's warning against a fondness for silence that leads to disgust with action [source: Ching pp. 106–108] gives a culturally congruent reason to rebalance. Assess for depression and meditation-related difficulties (B5, B6).
  • Rupture: the therapist's challenge felt as disrespect to the tradition or to elders. Acknowledge it and repair. Invoke the tradition's own ideal of sincere, tactful counsel (忠告而善道之) [source: Gong 2015] as the standard you are aiming for. Ask how the client would like to be challenged.
  • Idealising the therapist as a sage-teacher, or asking for moral verdicts. Restate roles (B7) and refer doctrinal questions to teachers or scholars (B4).
  • Moral self-righteousness. The client uses the junzi ideal to look down on others. Explore it gently using Wang's warning against putting on a sage's bearing [source: Ching p. 100].
  • Moral injury or a serious past wrong. Hold space for grief and remorse. Use fault-correction as repair (A4), and assess suicidality when shame is intense. Follow current risk-assessment standards.
  • Teachers, groups and coercive control. Contemporary Confucian study is largely educational and academic. Independent investigations of teacher misconduct in this practice: none found in the sources consulted. In any group, watch for signs of coercive control: discouraging outside relationships or professional help, demands for secrecy, harsh public "correction", financial or sexual exploitation, and punishment for leaving. Support clients who leave a group, and attend to religious trauma, without labelling the group.
  • Children and adolescents. Where resolve-talk is used to justify harsh discipline or extreme study regimes, follow local safeguarding procedures. Seek the young person's assent as well as parental consent.
  • Health claims. Lizhi is a moral discipline. It is not presented as a treatment for any physical disease, and health questions go to the client's doctor.
  • Client from outside the tradition adopting it. Explore what draws them. Encourage learning from qualified teachers and scholarly translations, and avoid the therapist becoming the source of doctrine.

Sources

Web sources:

Further works cited [uncertain: not verified]: Farias et al. 2020, Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica (review of meditation adverse events); Treleaven 2018, Trauma-Sensitive Mindfulness; Cheetah House resources; Vieten et al. 2013 spiritual and religious competencies; DSM-5-TR Cultural Formulation Interview; APA Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct; the Zhu Xi (Cheng–Zhu) treatment of 立志; the Analects and Mencius on 志.

ICD-10-CM Z65.8, Other specified problems related to psychosocial circumstances (includes 'Religious or spiritual problem'), https://www.unboundmedicine.com/icd/view/ICD-10-CM/945432/all/Z65_8___Other_specified_problems_related_to_psychosocial_circumstances

← Previous · XIII-136Investigation of thingsNext · XIII-138 →Classical reading as cultivation