Atlas›Domain XIII · Contemplative & religious disciplines›Guide 294
Guide XIII-294

Solitude and hermitage

A 33 · L 52 · M 1514 interventions in the Trinity explorer
Client cardCompare
[source: …] where a claim comes from[uncertain] not confirmed in a primary source[synthesis] the writer's reconstruction

1. Introduction

Version followed: the Catholic eremitic life as defined in the Code of Canon Law (canon 603) and as the Carthusian Order describes its life in the cell; the Christian desert tradition (the Sayings of the Desert Fathers, Evagrius) for the classic account of difficulties in the cell; the Buddhist (Insight/Vipassana) personal or solitary retreat as Gaia House (Devon, UK) runs it; and the secular psychology of chosen solitude (Nguyen, Ryan and Deci). Clinical safety guidance follows the Varieties of Contemplative Experience research programme (Lindahl et al. 2017, PLOS ONE; Lindahl et al. 2020, Frontiers in Psychology) and Farias et al. 2020, Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica.

Solitude and hermitage is a cross-traditional family of practices, not a single method. In the Catholic tradition, the hermit dedicates life to the praise of God and the salvation of the world through stricter separation from the world, solitude, prayer and penance, and may be recognised as consecrated by public profession before the diocesan bishop under a plan of life the bishop approves [source: The Catholic Leader Q&A on canon 603; McDonough 2015]. The Carthusians live most of each day alone in a cell (a small house with a garden), but call the charterhouse a "communion of solitaries" and state that solitude is not valued for itself but as a means to union with God and with others [source: chartreux.org, The Carthusian way]. In the Buddhist setting, a solitary or personal retreat is self-directed silent meditation inside a retreat house, undertaken only after prior teacher-led silent retreats and subject to a teacher's approval and regular interviews [source: Gaia House, Personal retreats].

How change happens, as each frame holds it (attributed, not stated as fact): in the Christian frame, withdrawal and silence create the conditions for interior silence and union with God, and the cell itself is said to teach the monk ("Go and sit in your cell, and your cell will teach you everything", Abba Moses, as quoted by Ung 2013). In the Insight frame, silence and simplicity support calm and clearer seeing of the mind [source: Gaia House, About silence]. In secular research, brief chosen solitude has a "deactivation" effect: high-arousal feelings fall and calm tends to rise, while sadness or loneliness can also rise, less so when the solitude is freely chosen [source: Nguyen, Ryan & Deci 2017/2018].

The psychotherapist's role is not to teach solitude or direct a vocation. It is to help clients who choose solitude, hermitage or solitary retreat do so with self-knowledge, safety and support, in their own tradition and language; to screen before intensive or solitary retreats; to recognise and respond to adverse experiences; and to refer to or collaborate with teachers, spiritual directors and clergy when the client wishes [synthesis].

2. Framework

No source gives a session count or fixed format for therapy around solitude or retreat; the phases below are a clinical structure [synthesis] built around the steps the traditions themselves describe. Durations of retreats and of hermit life are set by the client, the tradition and its authorities, and are not targets in this guide.

The traditions' own stages (for orientation)

  • Catholic hermit: a sense of call tested over time with a priest, spiritual director or community; long formation; a written rule (plan) of life approved by the bishop; public profession of the evangelical counsels; spiritual direction continuing for life [source: McDonough 2015; The Catholic Leader]. McDonough reports that lay hermits may lack ongoing formation after initial discernment and must provide their own support, shelter and income.
  • Carthusian: aspirants first come as retreatants; retreats in a cell follow the community's liturgical rhythm and require prior experience of silent retreats; spiritual guidance is available [source: chartreux.org; Selignac Charterhouse, Carthusian retreat].
  • Buddhist personal retreat (Gaia House): a regular practice and graded prior experience of teacher-led silent Insight or Zen retreats, rising with the length of stay; an application asking about personal and medical history; an induction interview; required regular teacher interviews for longer stays, described as "essential to maintaining your well-being"; continuation subject to teacher approval [source: Gaia House, Personal retreats].

Therapy phases [synthesis]

  1. Exploration and meaning. Goal: understand what solitude means to the client, in their tradition, and what they hope for. Move on when the client's aims, tradition, authorities and supports are clear.
  2. Readiness and screening (before any intensive or solitary retreat or move to hermit life). Goal: identify risk factors and protective factors, and agree on whether, when and in what form to proceed. Move on when risk is understood and a plan exists, or the client chooses a less intensive form first.
  3. Preparation. Goal: a written safety and support plan, links with the teacher or director (with consent), grounding skills practised beforehand. Move on when the client can use grounding skills and knows the stop signals.
  4. During the retreat or solitary period. Goal: the tradition's own support (teacher interviews, direction) carries the work; the therapist is available by prior agreement only. Return to phase 2 thinking if warning signs appear.
  5. Re-entry and integration. Goal: help the client return to ordinary life, make sense of experiences in their own frame, and address any lasting difficulties. Move on when functioning is restored and any adverse effects are managed or referred.
  6. Ongoing review (for those living a solitary life). Goal: periodically check the balance of solitude and relationship, health, finances and mood.

3. Guiding principles

  • Client-led and tradition-led. The client's tradition and its authorities define the practice; practically, ask about and use the client's own words (cell, hermitage, retreat, self-retreat) and do not import another tradition's frame [synthesis].
  • Concepts are attributed. Union with God, acedia, the "noonday" struggle, insight and awakening are described as the tradition holds them; practically, say "in your tradition this is understood as…" rather than affirming or dismissing [synthesis].
  • Solitude is a means, not the goal. The Carthusians say their solitude serves union with God and others [source: chartreux.org]; practically, ask what the solitude is for and notice when it becomes an end in itself or an escape.
  • Solitude needs relationship. The Carthusians balance the cell with common life because "it would be easy for the solitary to live in illusion" [source: chartreux.org]; McDonough states that the vocation to solitude requires remaining in spiritual direction. Practically, every plan includes a named accompanier.
  • Chosen solitude differs from imposed isolation. Solitude chosen autonomously is linked to more calm and less loneliness than solitude that is not [source: Nguyen, Ryan & Deci]; practically, assess motive and choice before supporting any plan.
  • Readiness is graded. Institutions require prior teacher-led experience before solitary retreat [source: Gaia House; Selignac]; practically, support stepping up from accompanied to less accompanied forms, never the reverse.
  • Screen before intensity. In the Lindahl et al. (2020) sample, most reported challenges arose during intensive retreat [source: Lindahl et al. 2020]; practically, screen before any intensive or solitary retreat.
  • Adverse effects can happen to anyone. Farias et al. 2020, Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, concluded that adverse events occur in people with no prior mental health history; practically, discuss risk with every client, not only those with a diagnosis.
  • Neither pathologise nor miss illness. Many traditions expect some difficult experiences on the path [source: Lindahl et al. 2020]; practically, judge by impairment, control, insight and trajectory, not by content alone.
  • Trauma sensitivity. Intensive inward attention without support can destabilise trauma survivors [source: Treleaven 2018, publisher description]; practically, plan for arousal, dissociation and relational safety.
  • Health questions go to the doctor. Diet, sleep, fasting and austerity in solitary life are medical matters; practically, give no austerity, fasting or sleep prescriptions and route questions to the client's doctor [synthesis].
  • Stay in role. The therapist is not the client's spiritual director, confessor, teacher or vocational discerner; practically, refer such questions and keep boundaries clear [synthesis; spiritual-competency literature such as Vieten et al. 2013 [uncertain: not verified]].

4. Intervention inventory

The traditions' own methods (the hermit's rule of life, the Carthusian day of liturgy, prayer, reading and work in the cell, the Insight personal retreat schedule) are taught and supervised by their own authorities and are described in sections 1–2. The interventions below are the psychotherapist's work alongside them. Related secular and clinical approaches are covered elsewhere: Domain II (MBSR, MBCT, MSC, CFT), Domain VII (contemplative and Buddhist psychotherapy, spiritually integrated psychotherapy) and Domain IV (trauma-sensitive yoga). Related guides in this domain: 174 (poustinia), 203 (Benedictine, Cistercian and Carthusian monasticism), 243 (khalwa and forty-day chilla retreats), 293 (silence) and 295 (vigil).

4.1 Exploring what solitude means in the client's life and tradition

  • Purpose / when: First step whenever a client raises solitude, a hermit vocation, a solitary retreat or a wish to withdraw. Establishes meaning, tradition, authorities and motives [synthesis].
  • Steps: (1) Ask permission to talk about the spiritual side of the plan. (2) Ask which tradition, community or teacher the practice belongs to, and who has authority over it (bishop, community, teacher, director). (3) Ask what the client hopes solitude will give, in their own words, and note the tradition's terms (for example union with God, interior silence, insight). (4) Ask about past experiences of silence or retreat: what helped, what was hard. (5) Ask who else knows about the plan and how they see it. (6) Summarise back in the client's language and agree whether therapy should support the plan, explore it, or both.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Would it help to look at the spiritual side of this alongside the practical side?" "In your tradition, what is time alone in the cell meant to do?" "Who accompanies you in this: a director, a teacher, a community?"
  • Watch for: Meaning that is mostly about getting away (from conflict, shame, demands) rather than towards something; no accompanier; secrecy from all others. Working when the client can state aims, authorities and supports clearly.

4.2 Telling chosen solitude apart from isolation, loneliness and withdrawal

  • Purpose / when: When solitude might be serving depression, social anxiety, avoidance, grief or trauma rather than a spiritual aim. Grounded in the finding that autonomy for solitude buffers loneliness and low mood [source: Nguyen, Ryan & Deci]; the clinical steps are [synthesis].
  • Steps: (1) Ask how freely the solitude is chosen: "want to" versus "have to" or "can't face people". (2) Map mood, sleep, appetite, energy, hopelessness and suicidal thoughts. (3) Ask whether time alone leaves the client calmer and clearer, or flatter, sadder and more stuck. (4) Look at the balance with relationship: who the client still sees, talks to or prays with. (5) If depression or avoidance is driving it, name this gently, treat it, and agree that the spiritual plan can be revisited once mood improves.
  • Example language (illustrative): "When you picture being alone, is it more like a pull towards something or a push away from something?" "After a day on your own, how do you usually feel: more settled or more low?"
  • Watch for: Rising loneliness, sadness or rumination after solitude (Nguyen et al. found low-arousal negative feelings can rise in solitude, especially when it is not freely chosen); loss of all contact; neglect of self-care. Working when the client chooses solitude from a settled place and keeps meaningful contact.

4.3 Screening before an intensive or solitary retreat

  • Purpose / when: Before any intensive silent retreat, personal or solitary retreat, cell retreat or move into hermit life. Rationale: most challenges in the Lindahl et al. (2020) sample arose during intensive retreat; adverse events also occur without prior history [source: Lindahl et al. 2020; Farias et al. 2020, Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica]. Retreat centres themselves ask about personal and medical history and require prior teacher-led experience [source: Gaia House; Selignac]. The screening list is [synthesis].
  • Steps: (1) Current state: mood, anxiety, sleep, recent stressors, recent losses. (2) History: psychosis, mania or bipolar disorder, severe depression, suicidal crises, dissociation, PTSD and complex trauma, eating disorders, substance use; family history of psychosis or bipolar disorder. (3) Past meditation or retreat difficulties: anything that felt overwhelming, frightening, unreal, or did not settle after stopping. (4) Health: medical conditions, need for regular monitoring, any medication questions (route all medication questions to the prescriber; no advice from the therapist). (5) Practice history: regular practice, prior accompanied retreats, prior experience of silence. (6) Supports: teacher or director available during the retreat, the centre's interview and emergency arrangements, a contact outside. (7) Plans for austerity: ask whether fasting, sleep reduction, cold or other austerities are planned and route health questions to the doctor; the therapist gives no austerity guidance. (8) Share the picture with the client and agree an option: proceed with a plan, choose a more accompanied or less intensive form first, or postpone.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Retreats can bring up strong experiences, even for people who have never had mental health problems. Can we look at what might help you stay steady?" "Has anything in meditation ever felt too much, or not settled when you stopped?"
  • Watch for: Recent or active psychosis or mania, current severe depression or suicidality, very recent trauma or bereavement, unmanaged dissociation, no accompaniment, plans that combine solitude with sleep loss or fasting. These point to postponing or choosing a more supported form [synthesis]. Working when risk is understood and the client owns the decision.

4.4 Collaborative safety and support plan

  • Purpose / when: After screening, for anyone going into a solitary or intensive retreat or a solitary way of life [synthesis].
  • Steps: (1) Name the accompanier (teacher, director, retreat coordinator) and how they are reached; at Gaia House, concerns go to a teacher or coordinator, and essential communication with them is allowed within the silence [source: Gaia House, About silence]. (2) List the client's own early warning signs (for example sleep loss, racing thoughts, fear that does not pass, feeling unreal, losing the sense of being separate from images or thoughts). (3) Agree stop or step-down signals and what to do: tell the teacher, reduce or stop formal practice, use grounding (4.9), contact the outside person. (4) Agree whether and how the therapist is available, so the plan respects the retreat's silence. (5) Note emergency services and nearest medical care. (6) Write it down; the client keeps a copy.
  • Example language (illustrative): "If things get too strong, who will you tell first, and what will you do in the next hour?" "Stepping back from practice is part of the plan, not a failure."
  • Watch for: A plan with no named person; a belief that telling the teacher would be failure. Working when the client can say the plan back and agrees to use it.

4.5 Supporting the client's own rule or plan of life

  • Purpose / when: For clients living or preparing to live as a hermit (canonical or lay) or a solitary practitioner who want help making their rule workable. In the Catholic tradition the rule is the hermit's own, approved by the bishop and covering prayer, sacraments, dwelling, finances, social contact and outward ministry [source: McDonough 2015; The Catholic Leader]. The therapist's part is [synthesis].
  • Steps: (1) Clarify that the content of the rule belongs to the client and their authority (bishop, director, community). (2) With consent, look at the practical and psychological parts: sleep, food, exercise, medical care, money, contact with others, work, and what happens when unwell. (3) Identify gaps, such as no plan for illness, no human contact, or precarious income (McDonough notes lay hermits must support themselves). (4) Encourage the client to take spiritual questions to the director and health questions to the doctor. (5) Review periodically.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Your rule is between you, your director and your bishop. Would it help to look at how it fits your health and your finances?" "What does your rule say about when you are ill?"
  • Watch for: The therapist drifting into writing or judging the rule; rigid self-punishment in following it (see scrupulosity, section 5). Working when the rule is sustainable and approved by the right authority.

4.6 Brief chosen solitude as an everyday practice (secular adaptation)

  • Purpose / when: For clients without a religious frame, or as a small first step, who want to use time alone to calm down. Based on experiments in which brief, device-free time alone reduced high-arousal feelings and tended to increase calm [source: Nguyen, Ryan & Deci]. Its use as a clinical exercise is [synthesis]; no length is a target.
  • Steps: (1) The client chooses when and where to be alone, without devices. (2) They may sit quietly, read, or let thoughts go where they choose (choice of thoughts helped preserve positive mood in the studies). (3) Afterwards they note feelings: calmer, more tired, sadder, lonelier. (4) Review together and adjust: more or less time, a different setting, or pairing it with contact afterwards.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Pick a time to be on your own, phone away, doing nothing in particular. Notice how you feel afterwards, without judging it."
  • Watch for: Loneliness or low mood after solitude, especially if it felt imposed; use as avoidance. Working when the client chooses it freely and reports calm without lasting low mood.

4.7 Working with restlessness and acedia in the cell (within the client's tradition)

  • Purpose / when: For Christian clients in hermit or monastic life, or on a cell retreat, who report restlessness, boredom, aversion to their place and urges to leave. The desert tradition names this acedia: Evagrius describes hating what is present and desiring what is absent, so that hate "chases him out of his cell", and Abba Moses's counsel was to stay in the cell; Ung reads this as stability, staying, praying and working in one place [source: Ung 2013, quoting Evagrius via Harmless and the Apophthegmata]. The therapist's steps are [synthesis].
  • Steps: (1) Ask how the client's tradition and director understand the experience; use their terms. (2) Screen in parallel for depression (low mood, hopelessness, loss of pleasure, sleep and appetite change, suicidal thoughts), because acedia and depression can look alike. (3) If depression is absent, support the client in using the remedies their tradition gives, as their director guides (for example a steady rhythm of prayer and manual work). (4) If depression is present, treat it, and invite the client to bring the director in. (5) Explore the meaning of the urge to leave without assuming it is either temptation or wisdom; the client decides with their director.
  • Example language (illustrative): "In your tradition this restlessness has a name and a history. How does your director suggest you meet it?" "Alongside that, can we check whether your mood has dropped in a way that needs care too?"
  • Watch for: Hopelessness, self-harm thoughts, marked weight or sleep change, which call for clinical care whatever the spiritual frame. Working when the client feels steadier and depression has been ruled out or treated.

4.8 Trauma-sensitive adaptation of solitary practice

  • Purpose / when: For trauma survivors planning solitude or silent retreat. Treleaven's Trauma-Sensitive Mindfulness (2018) argues that meditation taught without trauma awareness can bring flashbacks, dissociation or retraumatisation, and organises its guidance around five areas: attention, arousal, relationship, dissociation and social context [source: Treleaven 2018, publisher description; exact principle wording [uncertain: not verified]]. Application to solitude is [synthesis].
  • Steps: (1) Ask whether being alone, silence, darkness, confinement or lack of contact has trauma associations (for example past isolation, neglect or confinement). (2) Agree on choice and control: the client can open a door, go outside, walk, move, look around, or end a period of practice at any time. (3) Shift attention outward when arousal rises: senses, the room, nature, physical work. (4) Keep relationship in the plan: a person to speak to, the teacher's interviews. (5) Watch for dissociation (numbness, unreality, losing time) and plan responses in advance. (6) Consider social context: power dynamics with teachers or communities, gender, culture, and whether the setting feels safe.
  • Example language (illustrative): "You are in charge of this. Opening your eyes, getting up or walking outside are always allowed." "Is being alone or in silence linked to anything hard from the past?"
  • Watch for: Flashbacks, shutting down, feeling unreal, panic in silence. Working when the client can notice rising arousal and bring it down with chosen actions.

4.9 Grounding and dose reduction

  • Purpose / when: When challenging experiences arise during or after solitude or retreat. Buddhist teachers in the Lindahl et al. (2020) study reported reducing or stopping practice ("cut it way, way back"), changing the type of practice, grounding activities to re-establish bodily presence and functioning, teacher contact, and for severe cases psychotherapy, psychiatric care and hospitalisation. The concrete activities listed below are [synthesis].
  • Steps: (1) Reduce or pause formal practice; this is a normal remedy, not failure. (2) Shift from inward to outward attention: practice with eyes open, walking, manual work, gardening, time outdoors. (3) Re-establish ordinary routines: regular meals, sleep, physical activity. (4) Add contact: speaking with the teacher, a friend, family. (5) Return to formal practice gradually, in a form the teacher and client agree, once stable. (6) If symptoms persist after stopping, worsen, or spread into daily life, move to clinical assessment (4.10).
  • Example language (illustrative): "For now, the most helpful practice may be less practice. Can we look at what keeps you grounded in your body and your day?"
  • Watch for: Symptoms that do not settle after stopping (a teacher in the study was concerned when fear would not go away "even if they stop meditating"); sleep loss. Working when sleep, functioning and sense of control return.

4.10 Telling spiritual crisis apart from psychosis, mania, depression or dissociation

  • Purpose / when: When a client reports unusual, intense or frightening experiences in solitude: altered sense of self, light or perceptual experiences, energy-like bodily sensations, fear or terror, or delusion-like ideas (all documented in the Varieties of Contemplative Experience research [source: Cheetah House VCE page, listing these papers]). Traditions may treat some difficult experiences as expected progress (for example, in Christian language, a "dark night"), so content alone is not diagnostic [source: Lindahl et al. 2020].
  • Steps: (1) Listen and ask the client how they and their tradition understand the experience. (2) Assess the markers Lindahl et al. (2020) report teachers using: duration; functional impairment; level of distress and whether it exceeds the person's capacity to hold it; insight and reality testing (for example losing the ability to see experiences as mental images); ability to control or contain the experience; being "stuck"; deterioration or spread into other areas of life; and suicidality or disruptive behaviour, which need action at once. (3) Assess for mania (reduced need for sleep, pressured speech, grandiosity), psychosis (fixed false beliefs, hallucinations with loss of insight), severe depression and dissociation, and arrange psychiatric assessment when present. (4) Where there is distress tied to a religious or spiritual experience, faith or practice without a mental disorder, the DSM code for a religious or spiritual problem (V62.89 / Z65.8) can be used to avoid misdiagnosis [source: Barrett 2020]. (5) With consent, involve the teacher, who often knows the person's practice history; teachers in the study said accurate assessment needs knowing a student over time.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Many traditions describe experiences like this. I would like to understand how it is affecting your sleep, your daily life and your sense of what is real, so we can work out what help fits." "Does your teacher know about this?"
  • Watch for: Loss of sleep for several nights, loss of insight, risk to self or others: urgent assessment. Over-pathologising expected experiences in a person who is functioning well. Working when the client feels understood and the right kind of help (spiritual, clinical or both) is in place.

4.11 Coordinating with teachers, spiritual directors and clergy

  • Purpose / when: When the client wishes, especially around retreats, hermit vocations and challenging experiences. The Catholic hermit vocation assumes continuing spiritual direction [source: McDonough 2015]; Gaia House requires regular teacher interviews for longer personal retreats [source: Gaia House]. Coordination steps are [synthesis].
  • Steps: (1) Get written consent stating what may be shared and for what purpose. (2) Agree with the client the roles: the teacher or director guides practice and spiritual meaning; the therapist addresses mental health. (3) Share only what serves the plan (warning signs, what to do if they appear). (4) Agree how each will contact the other if concerned. (5) Respect the authority structure: hermit questions go to the director or bishop, retreat questions to the teacher.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Would it help if I spoke with your director about how we can both support you? You decide what I share."
  • Watch for: A teacher who dismisses clear warning signs as progress, or a client who wants the therapist to overrule the teacher on spiritual matters. Working when roles are clear and the client feels supported by both.

4.12 Re-entry and integration after a retreat or solitary period

  • Purpose / when: After any intensive or solitary retreat, or when someone leaves hermit or monastic life. The steps are [synthesis].
  • Steps: (1) Plan the return before leaving: lighter commitments at first, a person to talk with. (2) Afterwards, ask what happened, in the client's own words and frame. (3) Normalise sensitivity to noise, crowds and speech after silence. (4) Check for lasting effects: sleep, mood, anxiety, perceptual changes, sense of self. (5) Help the client carry chosen elements into daily life (for example short times of chosen solitude, a rhythm of prayer). (6) Refer or treat lasting adverse effects; Cheetah House lists consultation and nervous-system specialist resources [source: Cheetah House VCE page].
  • Example language (illustrative): "Coming back from silence can be jarring. What has been easy, and what has been hard?" "What would you like to keep from that time?"
  • Watch for: Effects that persist or worsen; isolation that continues without choice; grief at leaving solitary life. Working when the client functions well and has made sense of the experience.

4.13 Supporting discernment of a solitary vocation without directing it

  • Purpose / when: When a client is considering a canonical or lay hermit life, entry to a Carthusian or other contemplative community, or a long period of solitude. Traditions test such a call over time with directors, priests and communities [source: McDonough 2015]. The therapist's part is [synthesis].
  • Steps: (1) State the boundary: the therapist does not judge whether a vocation is genuine. (2) Help the client look at psychological questions that sit alongside discernment: motives, relationships, grief, avoidance, health, money. (3) Encourage the client to bring these into spiritual direction. (4) If the community or bishop asks for psychological assessment, refer to a clinician who can provide one independently, rather than the client's own therapist, to avoid dual roles.
  • Example language (illustrative): "Whether this is your calling is for you and your director to discern. I can help you look at what else is going on as you discern it."
  • Watch for: Pressure from the client to be told it is or is not a vocation; using the plan to escape relationships or treatment. Working when the client brings a clearer picture to their director.

4.14 Choosing the right form and level of accompaniment

  • Purpose / when: When a client wants solitude but is not ready for full solitary retreat. Institutions offer graded options: group silent retreats with teacher support before personal retreats [source: Gaia House]; Gaia House suggests a more structured setting with shorter silent periods (The Barn, Sharpham Trust) for those who find full silence too difficult [source: Gaia House, About silence]; the Carthusian cell retreat requires prior silent-retreat experience [source: Selignac].
  • Steps: (1) Map the client's experience and supports. (2) List options from more to less accompanied: guided days, group silent retreat, structured retreat with work and conversation, personal retreat with interviews, solitary retreat. (3) Let the client choose the next step that fits screening results. (4) Review after each step before moving on.
  • Example language (illustrative): "What would be the next step that stretches you without leaving you on your own with it?"
  • Watch for: Jumping to the least supported option; shame about choosing a gentler step. Working when each step is completed safely and reviewed.

5. Handling problems

Background: adverse and challenging experiences. The Varieties of Contemplative Experience study (Lindahl et al. 2017, PLOS ONE) interviewed Western Buddhist meditators and teachers and built a taxonomy of meditation-related challenges, their influencing factors and remedies; later papers from the programme describe light experiences, changes in sense of self, energy-like bodily experiences, fear and terror, delusion-like ideas, worldview changes and dietary factors [source: Cheetah House VCE page]. The commonly cited domain list (cognitive, perceptual, affective, somatic, conative, sense of self, social) is [uncertain: not verified]. Farias et al. 2020, Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, reviewing 83 studies, found a pooled adverse-event prevalence of about 8%, much higher in observational than experimental studies; anxiety, depression and cognitive anomalies were most common, and adverse events occurred in people with no prior mental health history [source: Farias et al. 2020, Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, PubMed abstract]. Lindahl et al. (2020) report that most challenges in their sample arose on intensive retreat. Neither source isolates solitary retreat specifically; that solitude may add risk by reducing contact and oversight is [synthesis].

  • Overwhelm during a solitary retreat. Follow the plan (4.4): tell the teacher or coordinator, step down practice, ground (4.9). Teachers in Lindahl et al. (2020) said someone who stays overwhelmed for days should be removed from the retreat, and some practitioners were taken to psychiatric care. If the therapist hears of this remotely, help the client contact the teacher and, if risk is present, emergency services [synthesis].
  • Client wants to proceed despite red flags (recent psychosis or mania, severe depression, active suicidality). Share concerns plainly, explain the reasons, offer a more accompanied or later option (4.14), and, with consent, involve the teacher or director. Respect autonomy where capacity is intact; act on risk where it is not, following current risk-assessment practice [synthesis].
  • Teacher or community dismisses distress as "progress". Teachers in the study varied in how long they thought difficult stages should last [source: Lindahl et al. 2020]. Hold to function, sleep, insight, control and risk as the markers; offer to speak with the teacher (4.11); support a second opinion from another qualified teacher or a clinician [synthesis].
  • Loneliness and low mood in solitude. Expected for some: Nguyen, Ryan and Deci found low-arousal negative feelings can rise in solitude, less when it is freely chosen. Revisit choice (4.2), add contact, and treat depression if present [synthesis].
  • Solitude as escape or avoidance (conflict, shame, social anxiety, grief, trauma). Name the pattern without dismissing the spiritual aim; work on the avoided issue; the Carthusians' own warning that a solitary can "live in illusion" without common life can be used, if the client is Christian and finds it helpful [source: chartreux.org; application synthesis].
  • Non-adherence or rigidity with the rule of life. Some clients drop their rule; others follow it with harsh self-punishment. Ask how the director sees it; separate spiritual counsel (director's) from health and mood (therapist's) [synthesis].
  • Scrupulosity. Solitary life can intensify moral self-scrutiny, fear of sin, repeated confession or rigid rule-keeping. Where it looks like OCD (intrusive doubt, compulsive checking or reassurance, distress out of proportion to the tradition's teaching), offer exposure and response prevention adapted with the client's religious authority, so exposures stay within what the tradition permits. Clinical guidance such as the IOCDF's on scrupulosity is [uncertain: not verified].
  • Austerities: fasting, sleep reduction, cold, prolonged vigils. Traditions include penance in hermit life [source: canon 603 as summarised in The Catholic Leader], and the Carthusians caution that excessive preoccupation with diet can be "a search for the self" [source: chartreux.org]. Do not prescribe or set any austerity, fasting length or sleep schedule; ask about health effects, involve the doctor, and ask the director how the tradition moderates penance in illness [synthesis]. Eating-disorder signs need clinical care.
  • Physical illness in solitude. No solitary practice treats physical disease. Ensure the rule or plan includes medical care, a way to call for help and regular check-ups [synthesis].
  • Precarious life circumstances. McDonough notes that canonical and lay hermits must provide their own support, shelter and income; ask about money, housing, ageing and who would notice if the client became ill [synthesis].
  • Teacher power and high-control dynamics. Solitude reduces outside contact, so it can deepen dependence on a single teacher or group. Signs to explore: control of contact with family, discouragement of medical or psychological care, secrecy demands, financial pressure, punishment for leaving. Support the client's own judgement, keep contact with outside supports, and help with leaving and any religious trauma if they choose to leave [synthesis]. No teacher or group is named here as a wrongdoer.
  • Re-entry problems. Irritability, sensory overload, detachment from family, or difficulty working after retreat or after leaving monastic life: use 4.12; treat lasting effects [synthesis].
  • Rupture when the therapist advises postponing. Acknowledge the disappointment and the value of the client's aim; offer a stepped path rather than a refusal; let the client decide where capacity is intact [synthesis].
  • Contact during a silent retreat. Agree in advance whether therapy pauses or continues and under what conditions, consistent with the centre's rules on silence and its allowance for essential communication with teachers [source: Gaia House, About silence; plan synthesis].
  • Therapist's own commitments. A therapist who values or distrusts solitude, or who belongs to a tradition, should notice this in supervision and limit self-disclosure to what helps the client. The therapist is not the client's director, confessor or teacher; avoid dual relationships (for example also being a member of the client's community who assesses their vocation). Professional ethics codes (for psychologists, the APA Ethical Principles) apply; specific clauses are [synthesis]. Spiritual and religious competency frameworks such as Vieten et al. (2013) are relevant [uncertain: not verified].
  • Suicidal thoughts arising in solitude. Assess at once following current standards; increase contact; involve emergency services where risk is high; do not treat it as only spiritual [synthesis].

Sources

← Previous · XIII-293SilenceNext · XIII-295 →Vigil